Effect of distribution of fines on evolution of cooperation in spatial public goods game

doi:10.1088/1674-1056/ad5aee

Abstract In the realm of public goods game, punishment, as a potent tool, stands out for fostering cooperation. While it effectively addresses the first-order free-rider problem, the associated costs can be substantial. Punishers incur expenses in imposing sanctions, while defectors face fines. Unfortunately, these monetary elements seemingly vanish into thin air, representing a loss to the system itself. However, by virtue of the redistribution of fines to cooperators and punishers, not only can we mitigate this loss, but the rewards for these cooperative individuals can be enhanced. Based upon this premise, this paper introduces a fine distribution mechanism to the traditional pool punishment model. Under identical parameter settings, by conducting a comparative experiment with the conventional punishment model, the paper aims to investigate the impact of fine distribution on the evolution of cooperation in spatial public goods game. The experimental results clearly demonstrate that, in instances where the punishment cost is prohibitively high, the cooperative strategies of the traditional pool punishment model may completely collapse. However, the model enriched with fine distribution manages to sustain a considerable number of cooperative strategies, thus highlighting its effectiveness in promoting and preserving cooperation, even in the face of substantial punishment cost.

Keywords: public goods game fine distribution cooperation

Received: 22 April 2024
Revised: 26 May 2024
Accepted manuscript online: 24 June 2024

PACS:	02.50.Le	(Decision theory and game theory)
	02.50.Ng	(Distribution theory and Monte Carlo studies)
	02.60.Cb	(Numerical simulation; solution of equations)
	02.70.Uu	(Applications of Monte Carlo methods)

Fund: Acknowledgment Project supported by the Open Foundation of Key Laboratory of Software Engineering of Yunnan Province (Grant Nos. 2020SE308 and 2020SE309).

Corresponding Authors: Hong-Wei Kang
E-mail: hwkang@ynu.edu.cn

Cite this article:

Xing-Ping Sun(孙兴平), Yan-Zheng Bi(毕研政), Hong-Wei Kang(康洪炜), Yong Shen(沈勇), and Qing-Yi Chen(陈清毅) Effect of distribution of fines on evolution of cooperation in spatial public goods game 2024 Chin. Phys. B 33 090204

[1] Axelrod R and Hamilton W D 1981 Science 211 1390
[2] Axelrod R and Dion D 1988 Science 242 1385
[3] Nowak M A, Sasaki A, Taylor C and Fudenberg D 2004 Nature 428 646
[4] Rand D G and Nowak M A 2013 Trends in Cognitive Sciences 17 413
[5] Young C and Largent M 2007 Evolution and creationism: A documentary and reference guide (Westport, Connecticut: Greenwood Press) p. 43
[6] Bowles S 2006 Science 314 1569
[7] Hardin G 1968 Science 162 1243
[8] Szabó G and Hauert C 2002 Phys. Rev. E 66 062903
[9] Hauert C, De Monte S, Hofbauer J and Sigmund K 2002 Science 296 1129
[10] Nowak M A 2006 Science 314 1560
[11] Assenza S, Gómez-Gardeñes J and Latora V 2008 Phys. Rev. E 78 017101
[12] Lv S, Li J, Mi J and Zhao C 2020 Phys. Lett. A 384 126343
[13] Nowak M A and May R M 1992 Nature 359 826
[14] Rand D G, Dreber A, Ellingsen T, Fudenberg D and Nowak M A 2009 Science 325 1272
[15] Santos F C and Pacheco J M 2005 Phys. Rev. Lett. 95 098104
[16] Santos F C, Rodrigues J F and Pacheco J M 2005 Phys. Rev. E 72 056128
[17] Santos F C, Santos M D and Pacheco J M 2008 Nature 454 213
[18] Sasaki T and Unemi T 2011 J. Theor. Biol. 287 109
[19] Szolnoki A and Perc M 2010 Europhys. Lett. 92 38003
[20] Zhang C and Chen Z 2016 J. Stat. Mech. 2016 103201
[21] Sun X, Li M, Kang H, Shen Y and Chen Q 2023 Appl. Math. Comput. 445 127853
[22] Hua S and Liu L 2024 Expert Systems with Applications 237 121579
[23] Nakamaru M and Iwasa Y 2006 J. Theor. Biol. 240 475
[24] Eldakar O T and Wilson D S 2008 Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 105 6982
[25] Cui P and Wu Z X 2014 J. Theor. Biol. 361 111
[26] Szolnoki A and Perc M 2017 Phys. Rev. X 7 041027
[27] Ozono H, Kamijo Y and Shimizu K 2017 Sci. Rep. 7 14379
[28] Wang Q, He N and Chen X 2018 Appl. Math. Comput. 328 162
[29] Boyd R and Mathew S 2007 Science 316 1858
[30] Brandt H, Hauert C and Sigmund K 2006 Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 103 495
[31] Fowler J H 2005 Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 102 7047
[32] Xia C Y, Meloni S and Moreno Y 2012 Adv. Complex Syst. 15 1250056
[33] Wu Y e, Zhang Z, Yan M and Zhang S 2019 Chaos 29 113101
[34] Danku Z, Perc M and Szolnoki A 2019 Sci. Rep. 9 262
[35] Sigmund K, Hauert C and Nowak M A 2001 Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 98 10757
[36] Rockenbach B and Milinski M 2006 Nature 444 718
[37] Xia C, Wang J, Perc M and Wang Z 2023 Phys. Life Rev. 120 103683
[38] Wang J and Xia C 2023 Europhys. Lett. 141 21001
[39] Szolnoki A and Perc M 2015 Europhys. Lett. 110 38003
[40] Savani I, Bedeaux D, Kjelstrup S, Vassvik M, Sinha S and Hansen A 2017 Phys. Rev. E 95 023116
[41] Wang M, Kang H, Shen Y, Sun X and Chen Q 2021 Chaos, Solitons Fractals 152 111395
[42] Liu L and Chen X 2020 Knowledge-Based Systems 188 104835
[43] Wang X, Duh M and Perc M 2020 Phys. Lett. A 384 126391
[44] Liu L, Xiao Z, Chen X and Szolnoki A 2022 J. R. Soc. Interface 19 20210755
[45] Li K, Cong R, Wu T and Wang L 2015 Phys. Rev. E 91 042810
[46] Cao X B, Du W B and Rong Z H 2010 Physica A 389 1273
[47] Tian L L, Li M C, Lu K, Zhao X W and Wang Z 2013 Chaos, Solitons & Fractals 54 65
[48] Quan J, Zhou Y, Zhang M, Tang C and Wang X 2019 J. Stat. Mech. 2019 043402
[49] Fan R, Zhang Y, Luo M and Zhang H 2017 Physica A 465 454
[50] Ding H, Zhang Y, Ren Y, Shi B and Choo K K R 2018 Soft Comput. 22 1287
[51] Kang H W, Jin Z Y, Li M Y, Wang M, Sun X P, Shen Y and Chen Q Y 2023 Chin. Phys. B 33 030203
[52] Andreoni J, Harbaugh W and Vesterlund L 2003 Am. Econom. Rev. 93 893
[53] Hauert C, De Monte S, Hofbauer J and Sigmund K 2002 J. Theor. Biol. 218 187
[54] Hauert C 2010 J. Theor. Biol. 267 22
[55] Orbell J M and Dawes R M 1993 Am. Sociol. Rev. 58 787
[56] Sefton M, Shupp R and Walker J M 2007 Econom. Inquiry 45 671
[57] Walker J M and Halloran M A 2004 Exp. Econom. 7 235
[58] Cressman R, Wu J J, Li C and Tao Y 2013 Biol. Theory 8 158
[59] Dong Y, Zhang B and Tao Y 2016 Sci. Rep. 6 28809
[60] Putterman L, Tyran J R and Kamei K 2011 J. Public Econom. 95 1213
[61] Traulsen A, Röhl T and Milinski M 2012 Proc. R. Soc. B 279 3716
[62] Wu J J, Li C, Zhang B Y, Cressman R and Tao Y 2014 Sci. Rep. 4 6421
[63] Yang C L, Zhang B, Charness G, Li C and Lien J W 2018 Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 115 9968
[64] Li M, Kang H, Sun X, Shen Y and Chen Q 2022 Chaos, Solitons Fractals 164 112747
[65] Helbing D, Szolnoki A, Perc M and Szabó G 2010 New J. Phys. 12 083005
[66] Szolnoki A, Szabó G and Perc M 2011 Phys. Rev. E 83 036101

[1]	Discreet investors exert greater influence on cooperation in the public goods game Hong-Wei Kang(康洪炜), Zhan-Yao Jin(金展瑶), Ming-Yuan Li(李明远), Mie Wang(旺咩), Xing-Ping Sun(孙兴平), Yong Shen(沈勇), and Qing-Yi Chen(陈清毅). Chin. Phys. B, 2024, 33(3): 030203.
[2]	Evolution of donations on scale-free networks during a COVID-19 breakout Xian-Jia Wang(王先甲) and Lin-Lin Wang(王琳琳). Chin. Phys. B, 2022, 31(8): 080204.
[3]	Reputational preference and other-regarding preference based rewarding mechanism promotes cooperation in spatial social dilemmas Huayan Pei(裴华艳), Guanghui Yan(闫光辉), and Huanmin Wang(王焕民). Chin. Phys. B, 2021, 30(5): 050203.
[4]	Fitness of others' evaluation effect promotes cooperation in spatial public goods game Jian-Wei Wang(王建伟), Rong Wang(王蓉), and Feng-Yuan Yu(于逢源). Chin. Phys. B, 2021, 30(12): 128701.
[5]	Simulation study on cooperation behaviors and crowd dynamics in pedestrian evacuation Ya-Ping Ma(马亚萍), Hui Zhang(张辉). Chin. Phys. B, 2020, 29(3): 038901.
[6]	The evolution of cooperation in public good game with deposit Xian-Jia Wang(王先甲), Wen-Man Chen(陈文嫚). Chin. Phys. B, 2019, 28(8): 080201.
[7]	Methodical review of the literature referred to the dye-sensitized solar cells: Bibliometrics analysis and road mapping Karwan Wasman Qadir, Qayyum Zafar, Nader Ale Ebrahim, Zubair Ahmad, Khaulah Sulaiman, Rizwan Akram, Mohammad Khaja Nazeeruddin. Chin. Phys. B, 2019, 28(11): 118401.
[8]	Benefit community promotes evolution of cooperation in prisoners' dilemma game Jianwei Wang(王建伟), Jialu He(何佳陆), Fengyuan Yu(于逢源), Wei Chen(陈伟), Rong Wang(王蓉), Ke Yu(于可). Chin. Phys. B, 2019, 28(10): 108703.
[9]	Evacuation flow of pedestrians considering compassion effect Yu-Zhang Chen(陈煜章), Ming Li(李明), Rui Jiang(姜锐), Mao-Bin Hu(胡茂彬). Chin. Phys. B, 2018, 27(8): 088901.
[10]	Stochastic evolutionary public goods game with first and second order costly punishments in finite populations Ji Quan(全吉), Yu-Qing Chu(储育青), Wei Liu(刘伟), Xian-Jia Wang(王先甲), Xiu-Kang Yang(阳修康). Chin. Phys. B, 2018, 27(6): 060203.
[11]	On fairness, full cooperation, and quantum game with incomplete information Zhen-Zhou Lei(雷振州), Bo-Yang Liu(刘博阳), Ying Yi(易英), Hong-Yi Dai(戴宏毅), Ming Zhang(张明). Chin. Phys. B, 2018, 27(3): 030202.
[12]	Improving the secrecy rate by turning foes to allies: An auction scheme Ma Ya-Yan (马亚燕), Wang Bao-Yun (王保云). Chin. Phys. B, 2015, 24(9): 090209.
[13]	Zero-determinant strategy：An underway revolution in game theory Hao Dong (郝东), Rong Zhi-Hai (荣智海), Zhou Tao (周涛). Chin. Phys. B, 2014, 23(7): 078905.
[14]	Hysteresis behavior and nonequilibrium phase transition in a one-dimensional evolutionary game model Hua Da-Yin (华达银). Chin. Phys. B, 2013, 22(4): 040512.
[15]	Effects of information asymmetry on cooperation in the prisoners’ dilemma game Wang Xi-Peng(王锡朋), Jiang Luo-Luo(姜罗罗), and Wang Bing-Hong(汪秉宏) . Chin. Phys. B, 2012, 21(7): 070210.

[1]	ZHOU HAI-JUN (周海军), XU XIANG-YUAN (许祥源), HUANG WEN (黄雯), LI LIANG-QUAN (李良权), CHEN DIE-YAN (陈瓞延). STUDY OF HIGH-LYING EXCITED STATES OF RARE-EARTH ELEMENT Dy BY LASER RESONANCE IONIZATION SPECTROSCOPY[J]. Acta Physica Sinica (Overseas Edition), 1992, 1(1): 19 -26 .
[2]	HU CHENG-ZHENG (胡承正), DING DI-HUA (丁棣华), YANG WEN-GE (杨文革). EXPRESSION OF THE ELASTIC ENERGY IN TWO-DIMENSIONAL QUASICRYSTALS[J]. Acta Physica Sinica (Overseas Edition), 1993, 2(1): 42 -47 .
[3]	XU SHI-HONG (徐世红), XU PENG-SHOU (徐彭寿), LI JIA (李嘉), MA MAO-SHENG (麻茂生), ZHANG YU-HENG (张裕恒), XU ZHEN-JIA (许振嘉). A STUDY ON ABSORPTION OF Na ATOMS ON Si(100) 2×1 SURFACES WITH DV-X_$\alpha$ METHOD[J]. Acta Physica Sinica (Overseas Edition), 1993, 2(10): 745 -753 .
[4]	Lü HUI-BIN (吕惠宾), R.E.BURGE, D. N. QU, X. YUAN. EXPERIMENTAL STUDY OF DIFFRACTIVE PROPERTIES OF WAVELENGTH-SIZED SINGLE GROOVES COATED WITH GOLD FILM[J]. Acta Physica Sinica (Overseas Edition), 1993, 2(3): 180 -189 .
[5]	LIN CHENG-LU (林成鲁), P.L.F.HEMMENT, LI JIN-HUA (李金华), SHI ZUO-YU (施左宇), Y.LI, J.A.KILNER. FORMATION OF A BURIED LAYER OF ALUMINIUM NITRIDE BY HIGH DOSE N₂⁺ IMPLANTATION INTO ALUMINIUM[J]. Acta Physica Sinica (Overseas Edition), 1993, 2(5): 376 -385 .
[6]	ZHANG HUI-YUN (张慧云), WANG YIN-JUN (王荫君). TEMPERATURE DEPENDENCE OF ANISOTROPY IN Co/X(Pt, Au, Ag, Ni) MULTILAYER FILMS[J]. Acta Physica Sinica (Overseas Edition), 1994, 3(10): 780 -787 .
[7]	XIA HUA (夏桦), ZHANG WEI (张维), HU AN (胡安), JIANG SHU-SHENG (蒋树声), ZHANG XING-KUI (张杏奎). BRILLOUIN LIGHT-SCATTERING INVESTIGATION OF ELASTIC ANOMALY FROM SUPERLATTICES[J]. Acta Physica Sinica (Overseas Edition), 1994, 3(2): 141 -149 .
[8]	QIAN BAO-LIANG (钱宝良), LIU YONG-GUI (刘永贵). THREE-DIMENSIONAL ANALYSIS OF ELECTROMAGNETICALLY PUMPED FREE-ELECTRON-LASER[J]. Acta Physica Sinica (Overseas Edition), 1994, 3(5): 345 -352 .
[9]	ZHANG XING-YUAN (张兴元), TAKEO FURUKAWA. LOW-TEMPERATURE LOW-FREQUENCY DIELECTRIC RELAXATIONS IN VDF(81)/TeFE(19) COPOLYMERS[J]. Acta Physica Sinica (Overseas Edition), 1994, 3(5): 374 -383 .
[10]	SHI JUN-JIE (史俊杰), DAI XIAN-QI (戴宪起), PAN SHAO-HUA (潘少华). INTERSUBBAND OPTICAL ABSORPTION IN SEMICONDUCTOR SUPERLATTICES WITH COMPLEX BASES[J]. Acta Physica Sinica (Overseas Edition), 1994, 3(6): 413 -425 .

Viewed

Full text

Abstract

Cited

Metrics
Related Articles

Effect of distribution of fines on evolution of cooperation in spatial public goods game

Cite this article:

Online attention