† Corresponding author. E-mail:
Project supported by the Union Research Centre of Advanced Spaceflight Technology (Grant No. USCAST2013-05), the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant Nos. 61170228, 61332019, and 61471239), and the High-Tech Research and Development Program of China (Grant No. 2013AA122901).
We propose a new framework combining weak measurement and second-order correlated technique. The theoretical analysis shows that weak value amplification (WVA) experiment can also be implemented by a second-order correlated system. We then build two-dimensional second-order correlated function patterns for achieving higher amplification factor and discuss the signal-to-noise ratio influence. Several advantages can be obtained by our proposal. For instance, detectors with high resolution are not necessary. Moreover, detectors with low saturation intensity are available in WVA setup. Finally, type-one technical noise can be effectively suppressed.
In the theory of quantum mechanics, the process of measuring an unknown state of a system by a meter can be described in two steps: coupling the system with the meter and measuring the meter to get information. For a standard projective measurement, where the coupling is strong, the outcome must be one of the eigenvalues of the system. On the other hand, when the coupling is weak, Aharonov, Albert and Vaidman (AAV) showed that there is a very strange phenomenon that the outcome could be outside the range of the eigenvalues by means of appropriate pre-selection and post-selection on the system. This phenomenon is called weak value amplification (WVA), which plays a significant role in parameter estimation in recent years.[2–11]
So far, many theories and experiments of WVA assume that the meter state is pure.[1,12] However, in some cases, preparing a pure state can be difficult because decoherence is easily induced by environmental disturbance.[13–15] In Ref. , Young-Wook Cho, et al. considered this problem and proposed a new scheme applying incoherent meter state to decrease the experimental difficulty. They used pseudo-thermal light instead of laser to repeat the AAV experiment and confirmed the feasibility.
On the other hand, in the AAV weak measurement experiment with photon position as the meter, beam after post-selection is directly collected by a charge-coupled device (CCD).[7,16] Though simple operation and calculation it has, larger displacement and better performance cannot be obtained for lack of sufficient data. It is natural to ask whether an improvement can be achieved by using different detection techniques.
Recently in Ref. , Young's double-slit interference experiment was implemented by second-order correlation detection, which was first proposed by Hanbury Brown and Twiss. Researchers found that more data could be collected through two-dimensional second-order correlated function patterns and varied scanning methods, which effectively improved the imaging resolutions.
Inspired by this idea, in this paper, we propose a new scheme combining second-order correlated technique with pseudo-thermal light source to realize WVA. We find that WVA phenomenon can be observed from second-order correlated detection. By applying two-dimensional second-order correlation function patterns, we obtain different WVA amplification factors by means of varied scanning methods.
In the AAV weak measurement scheme, the interaction between a system and a meter can be described by a Hamiltonian:
where g is the coupling constant, Â is the hermitian operator of the system, and P̂ is the momentum operator. The initial state, which is denoted as |i〉|ϕ(x)〉, is converted to be
where |ϕ(x)〉 is denoted as the meter, and |i〉 is the pre-selected system state. Here we assume that the pre-selected state |i〉 is the polarized state of a single photon in the horizontal-vertical basis, which can be denoted as |i〉 = cosα|H〉 + sinα|V〉. Similarly, the post-selected state is |f〉 = cosβ|H〉 + sinβ|V〉. After post-selection, the meter state evolves as
where the high-order term of g is neglected and Aw = 〈f|A|i〉/〈f|i〉 is defined as the weak value.
The feature of the weak value is that it can be arbitrarily large when the pre-selected state and post-selected state are nearly orthogonal. By choosing α = π/4, β = α + π/2 + ɛ, the weak value can be calculated to a simple form which equals
where ɛ is a constant and can be infinitely small.
In our proposal, the experimental setup is shown in Fig.
The optical field in the source plane is represented by E(x). According to the optical system theory, the optical field in the detect plane is
where E(xi), i = 1,2 is the optical field in the reference and signal detector plane, respectively. And hi(xi,x0), i = 1,2 is the impulse response function of the reference arm and the signal arm, respectively. The second-order correlation function of any two points between two detector plane is defined as G(2)(x1,x2)[20,21]
Substituting Eq. (
where I(xi), i = 1,2 is the intensity of the two detectors, and G(1)(x1,x2) is the first-order correlation function.
The second-order correlation function in Eq. (
We assume that the pseudo-thermal light is completely incoherent and satisfies the Gaussian type. Therefore, the term of first-order correlation function is
where G0 is a constant and w0 is the beam waist. x01, x02 are the points at any positions in the source plane.
In the signal arm, we assume that the two polarizers are thin enough that their thickness can be neglected. Consequently, both of the polarizers have no effect on the propagation of the light. After the weak-coupled process in the quartz plate, the emission of the beam contains two components, the ordinary and the extraordinary light. In the extraordinary light, the quartz plate will induce a distance d due to birefringence and a phase difference θ. So the impulse response function will be written into the sum of two terms. Therefore, according to the Fresnel-diffraction approximation, the impulse response function of the signal arm can be written as
where α and β are angles of pre-selected state and pro-selected state, respectively. k is the wave vector and λ is the wavelength of the pseudo-thermal light, z2 is the distance between the source and the detector D2.
In the reference arm, the light will directly propagate from the source to the detector D1. Thus, the impulse response function is
where z1 is the distance between the source and the detector D1.
Substitute Eqs. (
where Ĩ(x1/λz) is the Fourier transform of I(x0) under the condition of z1 = z2 = z.
The position of the detector on the signal arm is fixed. And, we set this fixed position at the center of the signal plane. Thus the intensity fluctuation is
For a small d, from setting α = π/4, β = α + π/4 + ɛ, ϕ = 2π, equation (
where Aw is the weak value and w1 = λz/π w0.
From Eq. (
In fact, from Eq. (
We replace the one-point detector of reference arm in Fig.
By choosing different lines on the two-dimensional second-order correlation function figure, any displacements of AAV weak measurement will be obtained. If we rotate the scanning line along different direction clockwise, we can get larger displacements and amplifications than that in the traditional weak measurement. For example, line b describes the case where we just proposed above. Notice that, scanning the detectors through this line cannot get the largest displacement and amplification. Also, the curve is shown in Fig.
where N is the average photons after post-selection and σ is the standard deviation of the intensity fluctuation curve.
And the minimum resolvable signal dmin is denoted as
Since the post-selection is fixed in our setup and the scanning methods do not change the average photons, N remains constant. Because the analytical solution is hard to derive, we make a numerical simulation of σ and Aw in each scanning method. The variation tendency between σ and Aw is shown in Table
We can see clearly that the ratio between Aw and σ varies in a very small range, and thus we can conclude that both SNR and dmin are independent of scanning methods.
Though, the SNR and resolution cannot be improved whatever scanning methods we choose in our proposal. The advantages are remarkable. First, large displacement will decrease the resolution requirement for detectors. Besides, due to post-selection probability, detectors with low saturation intensity is allowed to use in WVA setup. Finally, it can also reduce type-one technical noise which has been investigated before.
In this paper, we propose a new scheme to implement AAV weak measurement. The theoretical analysis manifests that WVA experiment can also be realized through second-order correlated technique. Moreover, we set up two-dimensional second-order correlated function pattern and describe how the amplification can be improved by choosing different scanning lines. Our theoretical model will pave the way to apply WVA setup in second-order correlated systems, such as ghost imaging. Furthermore, high amplification can reduce technical requirement for devices which lowers the cost and decreases experiment difficulty. Finally, WVA can effectively reduce technical noise. We believe our theory can have a bright prospect for weak measurement and second-order correlated technique.